The EU’s (Not-So) Fast Track for Biocontrols

With each passing year, it seems regulatory agencies around the world have made it more difficult for manufacturers to introduce traditional crop protection chemicals, which in part, has led to wider research into and acceptance of biocontrol solutions. The challenge for many companies, though, is that in several countries and regions those regulatory agencies treat biocontrol products the same way they have traditional chemistries, meaning it can take years to bring a product to market.

Willem Ravensberg, President IBMA
Willem Ravensberg, President IBMA

In countries that do offer a fast track for biocontrol products, companies can cut the time it takes to bring products to market, sometimes by years. While high-value specialty crops have employed biocontrols for decades, growers of row crops have begun embracing them as part of their crop protection strategies.

Gaining Acceptance
“Biocontrol has been standard in greenhouse crops for 30 to 40 years, and biopesticides are readily used in IPM programs,” says Willem Ravensberg, president of the International Biocontrol Manufacturers Association (IBMA). “In outdoor crops they are more recent and less well known and accepted. But issues with the conventional chemicals such as resistance, residue limits, honey bee problems, and political programs focusing on reduction of the use of chemicals bring changes and give options for biopesticides.”
Of course the pressure to move from traditional crop protection products is not only from regulators. There is pressure from consumers and retailers to produce food with less residue, which more or less forces growers to choose alternatives.
“Slowly biopesticides are being used more by growers, but it takes time before they understand them and rely on them,” Ravensberg says. “It is part of a changing crop protection to IPM, which needs more knowledge of pests and diseases and the way to control them. But every grower sees that this is the way the future crop protection will go.”
It’s for reasons like that IBMA is working with the EU Commission to rewrite the rules on biocontrol registration.

In the EU
In a nutshell, the EU has a two-tiered system. First a substance must be approved EU level. Second, each member state (country) has the opportunity to approve it.
“There is a fast-track system for low-risk products based on low risk substances,” Ravensberg says. A member state then has 120 days to decide whether to approve an application for low-risk plant protection products.
“The problem, however, is that the initial list of criteria for low-risk substances are not appropriate for biopesticides (because they were designed for chemicals),” Ravensberg says. “Since the publication of this law in 2009, IBMA has been trying to get this changed, and the expectation is now that low-risk criteria for biopesticides will be approved late this autumn, after so many years.”
Ravensberg says that beginning in 2017, companies will know the criteria and then can develop active substances that will meet these criteria.
“After approval of such a low-risk active substance, which still takes three to four years, the authorization of a low-risk product may take place and companies will benefit from the 120-days procedure.”
Still, each member state has the opportunity to make its own decision.
“This is an issue, for sure, for product authorizations,” Ravensberg says. “Countries may have so-called national requirements. This is not often the case for biologicals. But the way evaluators make their assessments varies per country because of different levels of experience with biopesticides, level of understanding of these products, and one of the issue areas is evaluation of efficacy.”
This means that products with the same dossier could have different approved labels in different countries. There is hope that a coordinated effort will lead to the development of a guideline for evaluation of efficacy trials both for the applicant as well as the evaluators, which should give a more harmonized approach. That is something IBMA is working on with regulators.
“Mutual recognition of product approvals should provide this harmonization already, but lack of confidence, etc. often leads to a repeat of dossier evaluations and consequently more time and expenses,” Ravensberg says.
One other factor could help lead to greater acceptance of these products throughout the EU.
The interest of the large multinationals that acquired biopesticide companies and are now gradually bringing biopesticides to the market could have an impact on grower acceptance, Ravensberg says.
“Growers have a long history with those companies and this may help building more trust in bio,” he says. “And the direction our societies are developing towards a more sustainable, durable and bio-based economy, towards more green. This changes the consumer needs, and retailers and NGOs further develop that. Further the pace with which new biopesticides are developed, their numbers, and research in this area and new technologies will offer many new possibilities for the grower in the
near future.”

Contact Dan: [email protected]


Leave a Reply



Terramera Gets EPA Approval for Biocontrol Product

Terramera announced the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency approved registration of its novel, broad-spectrum agricultural insect, fungal disease, and mite control


FMC Launches Insecticide/Fungicide

FMC Corp. has launched Ethos 3D insecticide/fungicide, formulated specifically for the novel 3RIVE 3D in-furrow application system that converts traditional


Marrone in Distribution Deal with Input Supplier in Turkey

Marrone Bio Innovations, Inc., a leading global provider of bio-based pest management and plant health products, announced that it has


How the Biopesticide and SMART-TECH Industries Create a “Blue Ocean” of Uncontested Crop Protection Market Space (Part 4)

Editor’s note: This is the fourth of seven articles in a series on Strategic R&D Management in AgChem and BioScience


Bayer Biological Product Registered in France

Bayer said its Serenade ASO fungicide/bactericide has received registration in France for foliar and soil applications on a wide range


Bayer Seeking Biologicals Partnerships

Bayer says it is seeking partners as it looks to increase its presence in the biologicals market. The company is

Wheat field

How ‘Softer Chemistry’ in Crop Protection Addresses Increased Emphasis on Safety

With the recent implementation of the Food Safety Modernization Act, a spotlight is now being shone on the need for

Pam Marrone

Marrone Enters Distribution Partnership in Vietnam, Cambodia

Key factors driving the rapid adoption of biologicals in Vietnam include pesticide residue problems in agro-products for local consumption, new requirements for Maximum Residue Levels on agro-products imported to the EU and U.S., and a growing number of banned pesticides.


STK REGEV Biofungicide Now Registered in Argentina

STK bio-ag technologies, the innovative Israeli-based leader in bio-ag technologies for sustainable crop protection and aquaculture, has announced its ‘hybrid’


BioConsortia Promotes Dr. Hong Zhu to Sr. VP of Research and Development

BioConsortia, Inc., innovator of microbial solutions for natural plant trait enhancement and yield improvement, has promoted Dr. Hong Zhu to


Marrone Bio Innovations Submits Novel Bioherbicide for EPA Approval

Marrone Bio Innovations, Inc. (MBI), a leading provider of bio-based pest management and plant health products for the agriculture, turf


PepsiCo in Deal with Arysta LifeScience Chile on Biological Products

Under the agreement, the select group of Chilean potato farmers that supplies PepsiCo on an exclusive basis will use the solutions from the Arysta LifeScience Pronutiva program, which combines traditional crop protection inputs with biological solutions.


Biorational Processes in Biopesticide Discovery and Development

Agchem companies are expanding their biopesticide R&D and portfolios, driven by stricter pesticide regulatory requirements, consumer awareness regarding hazards caused


3 Questions with BioTecnologie BT’s Piffanelli on EU Regulatory Environment

BioTecnologie BT is a Perugia, Italy-based contract research organization (CRO) specialized in the regulatory testing of biopesticides and biostimulants.


Corbion CEO Tjerk de Ruiter Appointed as New EuropaBio Chairman

EuropaBio’s Executive Board and General Assembly of Members confirmed the appointment of Tjerk de Ruiter as Chairman of the association.


FaunaSmart, BioScience Solutions Form Innovative Collaboration in Crop Protection

FaunaSmart and BioScience Solutions have announced a cooperation within strategic business development and innovation strategies in crop protection. Harry Teicher,


FMC, Chr. Hansen Extend Collaboration on Natural Crop Protection

FMC Corp. and Chr. Hansen have announced a five-year extension of their collaboration to develop and commercialize natural solutions for the agricultural industry.


Tradecorp Acquires Spain’s Idai Nature

Idai Nature is currently present in 35 countries and has posted annual growth of more than 30% in recent years. The company’s consolidated revenues amount to 16 million euros.


A (Surprisingly Long) Biopesticide Timeline

The application of biopesticides in plant protection is certainly not a new innovation. A few examples are presented in the

Latest News


Clariant, Eastman Enter Distribution Agreement

Clariant, a world leader in specialty chemicals, and Eastman Chemical Company, a global advanced materials and specialty additives company, announced


What Does a Traceability Software Product Do in Agribusiness?

Editor’s note: This article was originally published on LinkedIn. I’ve been traveling over the last one week, on-boarding our first large


University of Utah Recognizes Aqua-Yield/Nano Institute Partnership in New Annual Report

In a newly-published annual report, the University of Utah’s Center for Technology & Venture Commercialization (TVC) touts the first-of-its-kind collaboration


China Could Subsidize Agribusiness Buying in Trade Truce

With a trade truce delaying escalation of tariffs between the U.S. and China into March, there is an opportunity for


Report: U.S. Farmers Still Planning Fewer Soybeans in 2019 Despite Promise of China Trade Deal

When President Donald Trump was having the highly-anticipated dinner with China’s President Xi Jinping at the G20 summit, farmers in