Regulatory Predictability Needed for an Industry Committed to Innovation

Howard Minigh
Howard Minigh, President and CEO of CropLife International

The crop protection industry helps millions of farmers grow their crops every year. From Asia to Africa and from Europe to the Americas, plant scientists are developing crop protection products to advance sustainable and productive agriculture to ensure global food security. We are a solutions-driven industry, but the challenges keep on coming.
The world’s population is growing by 80 million people every year and if nothing changes, by 2050 we will need our finite resources to meet the demands of two billion more people. Making the food security challenge even more difficult, farmers are growing food crops that must compete with 30,000 species of weeds, 3,000 species of nematodes, and 10,000 species of plant-eating insects — all of which are invading new geographies with a changing climate.
The crop protection industry continues to invest heavily in cutting-edge innovations to help farmers to meet these challenges. But innovation doesn’t come cheap and it is not easy. The cost of bringing a new crop protection product to market is $286 million — up more than 50% since the turn of the century — as product candidates meet an increasingly high performance bar for safety and efficacy. It now takes more than 11 years of research and development — three years longer than in 2000 — to bring a crop protection product to market and the average number of new molecules screened in order to discover one new crop protection product has increased from 52,000 in 1995 to 152,000 today.
Given the huge commitment required to bring new innovations to market, our industry needs predictable and risk-based regulations alongside robust intellectual property rights for companies to have the confidence to continue to invest in solutions. However, the increased politicization of regulatory decisions in Europe and around the globe is eroding that confidence.
One example is the EU’s proposed regulation on chemicals that could impact the human endocrine system — known as endocrine disruptors. The criteria for endocrine disruptors have been debated in the EU for several years, contributing to uncertainty over the final regulatory standard. The fear is that politics will trump science, and regulations will be based on inherent hazard rather than real risk of products. This unscientific approach, inconsistent with other global regulatory standards, could lead to delays in market access, trade disruptions and ultimately act as another disincentive to innovate.

“A further dent to industry’s confidence to innovate is from
the growing number of legal challenges calling for full disclosure
of data on crop protection products.”

The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) provides another example of how science can be pushed aside by opportunist attacks on industry. IARC’s mandate is to identify potential cancer hazards — it does not assess actual risk. Nevertheless, IARC monographs have been used by industry critics to create confusion among regulators around the world. Any resulting knee-jerk regulatory decisions undermine our industry’s incentive to invest in new products.

A further dent to industry’s confidence to innovate is from the growing number of legal challenges calling for full disclosure of data on crop protection products. The protection of Confidential Business Data, such as product composition and manufacturing processes, is vital for any industry to ensure inventors are rewarded for their investments and encouraged to continue research and development. This must not be compromised to satisfy a minority of powerful activists.
The plant science industry currently ranks in the top four global sectors for the most investment in developing new products, and rightly so — over the next 40 years the agriculture industry will need to expand food production to meet the needs of more than 9 billion people. Achieving this will require a continuous pipeline of new technologies to help farmers increase crop productivity, and for that to happen, we must insist on a predictable, science-based regulatory environment and strong data protection.

Topics: ,

Leave a Reply

Africa/Middle East

Africa/Middle East

AgTech Startup Wefarm Secures New Financing Round

Wefarm, the world’s largest farmer-to-farmer digital network, has secured $5 million in additional seed funding, led by Silicon-Valley based True

Africa/Middle East

Sub-Saharan Africa: Time for a Paradigm Shift to Sustainable Farming Practices

Farming in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) has remained fairly conventional over the years and involves intensive use of synthetic chemicals and

Africa/Middle East

VisionFund International Offers Climate Insurance Initiative for African, Asian Farmers

More than 690,000 families totaling up to four million people living in six low-income countries stand to benefit from a

Africa/Middle East

Bancella Expands African Footprint

Bancella Ltd., headquartered in Mauritius, has taken another step in growing the footprint in Africa by taking what is described

Africa/Middle East

Kenya Dairy Industry Sheds Light on Market Challenges, Opportunities

In December, I had the privilege to serve as a volunteer consultant with the USAID Farmer-to-Farmer (F2F) program in Kenya.

Africa/Middle East

Eastern African Nations Move to Harmonize Fertilizer Regulations

Eastern Africa countries are working to harmonize the region’s fertilizer market, a move that could improve not only demand for

Africa/Middle East

Changing the Narrative: It’s Not Just About Yield

For years now when someone outside the industry asks what I do, I give them the “elevator speech,” the 30-second

Africa/Middle East

Counterfeits Disrupt Uganda’s Agrichemicals Market

The outbreak of the Fall Armyworm (Spodoptera frugiperda) in East Africa in late 2016, particularly in landlocked Uganda, and the

Africa/Middle East

BRANDT Expands Relationship with Solagri Tunisia

BRANDT, a leading manufacturer of specialty products for the agriculture market, has signed an exclusive distribution agreement with Solagri Tunisia

Sanjay Sethi
Africa/Middle East

Sanjay Sethi, Phoenix Group Honored with Sustainable Initiatives Award

During the recently held Meet the Farmers Conference 2017 at the Waldorf Astoria, Palm Jumeirah in Dubai, Sanjay Sethi, Director

Africa/Middle East

Koppert Broadens its Activities in Africa

Leading biocontrol producer, Koppert Biological Systems, has extended its presence in Africa by opening a new subsidiary in the West

Africa/Middle East

Syngenta, USAID Renew Global Collaboration to Improve Food Security

Renewed MOU to develop agriculture in Africa, Asia and Latin America.

Africa/Middle East

U.S. Growers Cautiously Optimistic About Biostimulants

Long-awaited regulatory guidelines along with growing research will help promote wider use.

Africa/Middle East

Marrone Bio Innovations Signs Exclusive Distribution Agreement with Kenya Biologics Ltd. for Kenya and Tanzania

The agreement Includes Reysana™ (Regalia®), Grandevo®, Venerate® and Majestene®.

Africa/Middle East

Marrone Bio Innovations Signs Distribution Agreement in North Africa

ÉLÉPHANT VERT, which has 300 employees in five countries in Africa and Europe and develops and markets organic amendments, biofertilizers, biostimulants and 100% natural biopesticides made in four production units, will develop and market two of MBI's products in Morocco, Tunisia and Algeria:

Africa/Middle East

Liberia: Agro-dealers Cautioned on Safe Use of Inputs

The president of the National Agro-dealers Association of Liberia (NADAL) has cautioned agro-dealers in the country on the proper use

Africa/Middle East

‘Big Three’ Donors Team Up to Boost African Ag Transformation

Three of the biggest funders of African agricultural transformation have launched a new $280 million partnership at the 2017 Agricultural Green Revolution Forum in Abidjan.

Africa/Middle East

Africa Faces Annual $2bn-plus Maize Deficit if Fall Armyworm Poorly Managed

The Centre for Agriculture and Biosciences International (CABI) has confirmed that Fall Armyworm (FAW) has been reported in 28 African

Africa/Middle East

South African Grain Laboratory’s Crop Protection Division Accredited

The South African Grain Laboratory (SAGL) recently released an update on the status of its new Crop Protection Division’s accreditation,

Latest News


Bayer: Enzymes in Honeybees Determine Neonic Sensitivity

A joint study by Exeter University, Rothamsted Research and Bayer has discovered enzymes in honey bees and bumble bees that determine how sensitive they are to different neonicotinoid insecticides.


China Pesticide Market: Biopesticides, Fungicides Highlight 47 New Products Launched in 2017

In 2017, there were 47 new pesticides registered or launched in China, including 13 fungicides, five insecticides / acaricides /


Nichino America Launches Novel Fungicide

Flutianil, the active ingredient in Gatten, has specific activity against the fungal diseases that cause powdery mildew.

Seeds and Traits

Monsanto Previews Current, Future Pipeline Offerings

Even after the company launched dicamba-tolerant crops to the agricultural marketplace in 2017, Monsanto is gearing up for a busier


Understory Partners with Monsanto in Argentina

Disruptive edge computing weather network deployed in key agriculture regions in Argentina.