R&D Fears in the Age of DowDuPont

The proposed merger between U.S.-based Dow and DuPont would create the world’s largest crop protection and seed company — a combination of two competitors with top herbicides and insecticides portfolios and with a strong track record of bringing innovative crop protection and seeds products to the market.

DuPont CEO, Edward Breen
DuPont CEO, Edward Breen

But the $130-billion deal could be derailed after European regulators halted their investigation into whether it violates the bloc’s merger regulations in September.
Reuters reported that the EU antitrust enforcer will set a new deadline for its investigation once it has received key missing data from the companies. DuPont and Dow, which aim to close the deal in early 2017, had previously offered concessions that regulators said were insufficient, according to Reuters.
Worries that innovation will emerge as the loser from the deal (as well as the others, i.e., Bayer/Monsanto and ChemChina/Syngenta) are real, even more so with the crop protection industry grappling with a declining number of new active ingredients for years now.
That is, if the deals happen in the first place.
“I’m not convinced that all or any of (the three proposed mergers in the agrichemical industry) will go through, but consolidation will happen at some point in time,” Dr. Bob Fairclough of Kleffmann Group commented at the AgriBusiness Global Trade Summit in Orlando on Aug. 18.
DuPont, an early American innovator, not only announced that it would slash 10% of its work force, but CEO Edward Breen also said the company would cut spending on R&D in 2016 to between $1.6 billion and $1.7 billion, down from the $1.9 billion in 2015.

“Dow and DuPont are important innovators in the crop protection industry, which is characterized by a limited number of global companies with significant R&D capabilities. The transaction would lead to the elimination of one of the few companies able to develop and launch new active ingredients,” the European Commission said.
It isn’t only the Europeans who are concerned. The National Farmers Union was one of three U.S. groups that sent a letter urging the U.S. Department of Justice to block the deal. The letter explained that competitive R&D investments have been crucial for driving innovation in an industry where the probability of commercial success is relatively low due to the time and cost associated with bringing a trait from research to market.

Dow CEO, Andrew Liveris
Dow CEO, Andrew Liveris

NFU Government Relations Director Barbara Patterson told AgriBusiness Global, “NFU is very concerned that, should the mergers be approved, research and development efforts will be negatively impacted, particularly because they have been so crucial for driving innovation in the industry … R&D intensity has dropped off in recent years and USDA reports that increasing levels of concentration in agricultural input markets are no longer generally associated with higher R&D or a permanent rise in R&D intensity. This draws into question long-standing arguments that concentration is needed to generate economies of scale in R&D.”
Patterson also called to attention the growing problem of weed resistance, and how producers could suffer. “There have been some new advances that have helped with the issues of weed resistance, but very few. The majority of the new developments are based off old technologies that are combined to target resistance … Even producers in the northern part of the country, who were not impacted prior to 2006, are seeing severe resistance in weeds like horseweed, kochia, ragweed, and water hemp.”
Specifics on how the new R&D structure would look is not yet clear, but the companies have laid out some basics on the Agriculture company — one of the three entities into which the merged DowDuPont will be split.
Corporate headquarters for the Agriculture business will be in Wilmington, Delaware, where DuPont has been based for more than 200 years. Wilmington will include the office of the CEO and key corporate support functions. Sites in Johnston, Iowa and Indianapolis, Indiana will serve as global business centers, with leadership of business lines, business support functions, R&D, global supply chain, and sales and marketing capabilities.
The structure of the Agriculture company was specifically developed to ensure cost savings of $1.3 billion, DuPont has stated. Despite naysayers, both companies have stressed that the combination will create a U.S.-based leader that will deliver greater value and choice for growers.
In a statement to AgriBusiness Global, a DuPont spokesman said, “Science-based innovation will continue to be one of the primary drivers of growth for DowDuPont and the intended successor companies. We remain deeply committed to R&D and engineering that are business-driven and optimized to create solutions that serve the needs of our global customers for choice and value.”

Topics: ,

Leave a Reply



Cargill Looks to Crop Enhancement Inc. in Indonesia

Indonesian cocoa growers in Cargill’s extensive network are eager to expand their use of this effective, farmer-friendly solution that reduces the need for synthetic pesticides.


Bayer in New Alliance to Provide Solutions for Smallholders

The new alliance will develop sustainable and scalable business models with local partners to improve livelihoods and food security.


Agricultural Biologicals: Terms and Definitions

Pesticides are agents, substances or mixtures of substances used to prevent, destroy or control pests (including weeds) and diseases. Pesticides


Agrian Expands Crop Protection Product Label Database Business

Following a decade of rapid growth, the agricultural software company Agrian has opened a new office in Clovis, Calif., near Fresno.


Environmental Inspections to Bolster Chinese Glyphosate Prices in 2017

  Chemical industry research firm CCM predicts that that the price of glyphosate technical will fluctuate between $3,309 and $4,748/t

Africa/Middle East

It’s Time to Tap the Potential of Biological Products

BIOCONTROLS AFRICA, July 12-13 in Cape Town, marks our first event focused solely on biopesticide and biostimulant products. Our first


Dow, DuPont Merger Set to Close in Q1 2017

The merger between Dow AgroSciences and DuPont is set to close in the first quarter of 2017, according to a


Call For Ag Tech Startups: Apply To THRIVE’s Open Innovation Forum

THRIVE is looking for high growth ag tech companies with an in-market solution that are positioned to scale. The top 50


Monsanto, Dow in Global Option, Licensing Deal on Dow’s Exzact Precision Ag

Monsanto Co. and Dow AgroSciences announced that the companies have reached a non-exclusive global option and licensing agreement on Dow


Six Reasons Senior Executives Must Attend The First-Ever PrecisionAg Vision Conference

As I made a West Coast swing this spring to visit companies including The Climate Corp. and Planet Labs, there


China ICAMA Initiates Re-registration Investigation on 8 Pesticides

On 22 Jun 2016, China ICAMA released a circular to all provincial subdivisions on the risk investigation of eight pesticides:

Seeds and Traits

Monsanto Eyes India Exit for Bt Cotton

The Indian government capped Monsanto’s trade royalties at 49 rupees ($.73) per 450-gram pack of Bt cotton seeds, a 70%


New Book Examines Food Waste Across the Supply Chain

Humans have always wasted food, but the scale of the problem today is unprecedented. More than one-third of food produced


USDA Deputy Secretary Harden Steps Down

Agriculture Deputy Secretary Krysta Harden announced her plans to depart the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) at the end of


Monsanto to Build Cotton Seed Processing Plant

Existing cotton seed processing facilities in Arizona, Mississippi and Texas will continue to support manufacturing operations until summer 2017.

Africa/Middle East

Outlook 2016: Commodity Price Slump to Continue Through 2017

In the Great Recession that began in late 2007, the global economy sputtered on weak performance from advanced economies while


Sourcing Network Now Includes Biocontrols

The AgriBusiness Global Sourcing Network launched earlier this year with more than 450 companies and 5,000 AIs and formulated products


EU Dumps Glyphosate Tariff

The European Union will not renew its 30% glyphosate tariff on Chinese glyphosate that was suspended late last year and


Import Tariffs to Be Lifted on Napa Cabbage, Radish

The Korean Agriculture Ministry plans to temporarily waive tariffs on all imports of napa cabbage and radish until the end

Latest News


China Eases Pollution Campaign in Move to Offset U.S. Tariff Impact

China’s government announced it is scaling back its pollution control campaign this fall and winter, in an effort to offset


HELM Agro Fungicide Approved in California

HELM Agro US, Inc. announced that the California Department of Pesticide Regulations (CDPR) has approved Helmstar Plus SC fungicide for


Fungicide Use on the Rise in Indonesia

The global crop protection market in 2017 increased at a rate of 1.9% in nominal terms over that of 2016.


Bayer Biological Product Registered in France

Bayer said its Serenade ASO fungicide/bactericide has received registration in France for foliar and soil applications on a wide range


Paraguay: A Hidden Gem in the Agrichemicals Market

Whenever agchem players think of the South American markets, Brazil will be the one that comes to mind. It became