While Neonics Face Battle, Glyphosate’s Future Promising in EU

“How far is the Commission willing to go in being the ‘bad guy’ in the story? I’m a bit concerned there will be some compensating – ‘glyphosate came out OK, therefore we are going to be careful on neonics even if we don’t have evidence for it.’”– Jean-Philippe Azoulay, Director General, ECPA

Filter out the noise, and there it is: Science is poised to trump emotion in Europe — at least when it comes to glyphosate.

Despite fears that European farmers would lose the active after regulators failed to renew its reauthorization and instead issued an 18-month extension until the end of 2017, saying they needed additional data, it appears its future on the continent is solid.

It was IARC’s classification of glyphosate as a “probable human carcinogen” that grabbed all the headlines — never mind that mainstream media, more often than not, omitted the fact that IARC places things like red meat, barbeques, and the hairdressing profession into the same category.

But the classification that carries real weight came down in March. That decision, from the European Chemicals Agency’s (ECHA) Risk Assessment Committee, concluded that the available scientific evidence “did not meet the criteria to classify glyphosate as a carcinogen, as a mutagen or as toxic for reproduction.”

What is ECHA’s Risk Assessment Committee (RAC) exactly, and why is its determination so important? First, RAC is comprised of members from nearly all EU member states, who are nominated by the states and then appointed by the managing board of ECHA. They act as individual scientists and not on behalf of member states, RAC Chairman Tim Bowmer explained in a press briefing.

“Because of that construction, which is part of the REACH regulation, they have an independent opinion to give and I think that’s what they have done today (in concluding glyphosate is not a carcinogen,)” he said.

ECHA’s classification, together with the European Food Safety Authority’s risk assessment in late 2015 that also concluded glyphosate is unlikely to pose a carcinogenic hazard to humans, are poised to form the basis of the European Commission’s decision whether to renew glyphosate for another 15 years.

ECHA’s classification is in the process of being finalized and will be submitted to the Commission – most likely in April 2017 — whose decision should then come within six months.

Greenlighting glyphosate “would be the logical step, if (the Commission) bases their decision on risk management on data, evidence, and science,” Jean-Philippe Azoulay, Chairman of the European Crop Protection Agency, tells AgriBusiness Global.

He says he is confident that Europe will make a science-based decision.

“I’m optimistic about the future of glyphosate … Glyphosate enables green farming. I think this is going to be rediscovered once we get past the hype and noise following, hopefully, the reauthorization. I think the argument will be easier to make with less emotions,” Azoulay says. “I think the fact that the compound is safe, and has completely changed the way farmers are farming with no tillage and direct planting is going to be recognized more and more as we go into a more detailed debate on sustainable farming and good farming practices.”

It’s not that there are no lingering concerns — there are. It was political pressure that led to the extension put on glyphosate’s reauthorization in the first place, as well as the suspension placed on neonicotinoids for the past three years.

If regulators cave to political pressure, Azoulay says, the entire system loses credibility. “Our citizens, who do they trust — the next Twitter account? We have to be very responsible in the way we treat our experts and our agencies.”

NEONIC FUTURE UNCERTAIN
The path for neonicotinoids is nowhere near as certain, however.

In late March, a proposal came on the table from the Commission to expand the partial moratorium of the past three years to a complete ban, except in greenhouse crop applications, of the three key neonicotinoids: clothianidin, thiamethoxam, and imidacloprid. The draft regulations are set to be evaluated at the Commission’s next standing meeting in April 2017, and would come into force this year if they’re approved by a majority of EU member states.

“How far is the Commission willing to go in being the ‘bad guy’ in the story? I’m a bit concerned there will be some compensating — ‘glyphosate came out OK, therefore we are going to be careful on neonics even if we don’t have evidence for it, so we don’t look too bad,’” Azoulay says. “This is more my personal fear.”

Although it has not been revealed on which data the latest proposal is based, industry experts believe the Commission is relying on the European Food Safety Authority’s Bee Guidance Document, which was released in 2013 and never approved by the European Council.

“The Guidance Document was published under heavy pressure. It was not validated and was never approved by a standing committee, and it’s completely unrealistic,” says Azoulay, who explains that the conditions and demands were incredibly stringent, requiring testing of neonicotinoids over very large areas and under which most crop protection products would not pass.

The Commission’s own research, ironically, contradicts the Guidance Document. On Jan. 11, the Commission’s Joint Research Centre presented the main conclusions of its ex-post neonicotinoid study to the European Parliament, concluding that the temporary precautionary ban has not improved bee health but has led to increased costs to farmers and risks to crops and the environment.

Azoulay adds: “We’ve lost a million tons of oilseed rape, (and the moratorium has caused) caused 900 million euros of economic impact. The result is we have to import oilseed rape from Ukraine, Russia, and other countries where they use neonicotinoids, and they don’t have issues with bees and also export honey to Europe,” he says. “The whole thing doesn’t add up; it’s bizarre.”  •

Topics: , ,

Agrichemicals

Agrichemicals

Monsanto Sues Arkansas Regulator Over Dicamba Ban

Monsanto is challenging the restrictions as Arkansas edges closer to adopting a temporary ban on dicamba herbicides for next year.

Agrichemicals

Summit Agro USA Launches New Corn Herbicide

SHIELDEX 400SC controls a wide range of broadleaf and grass weeds, including troublesome weeds such as tall waterhemp, Palmer amaranth, giant ragweed and giant foxtail.

Africa/Middle East

Syngenta, USAID Renew Global Collaboration to Improve Food Security

Renewed MOU to develop agriculture in Africa, Asia and Latin America.

Bob Fairclough
Agrichemicals

U.S. Remains the Leading Crop Protection Market — For Now

Exclusive article by Dr. Bob Fairclough of Kleffmann Group.

Agrichemicals

Crop Protection Rebates: Playing the Game

From the earliest days of competitive selling, the concept of rewarding customer loyalty has been a page, if not a full chapter, in the capitalist playbook.

Agrichemicals

BASF to Acquire Bayer Seed, Herbicide Businesses for $7 Billion

The assets to be acquired include Bayer’s global glufosinate-ammonium non-selective herbicide business, commercialized under the Liberty, Basta and Finale brands, and seed businesses for key row crops in select markets.

Agrichemicals

Monsanto Announces Enhanced Label for XtendiMax

Updates include mandatory training, new record keeping requirements, and a Restricted Use Pesticide (RUP) designation.

Agrichemicals

EPA Sets Regulatory Actions on Dicamba for 2018

Manufacturers have voluntarily agreed to label changes that impose additional requirements for over-the-top use of these products next year.

Agrichemicals

China’s New Pesticide Rules Change How Products are Brought to Market

By Bo Yang, Jose Carvalho and Xiaohua He Dr. Knoell Consult Shanghai Co., Ltd China Ministry of Agriculture (MoA) has

Agrichemicals

Agricultural Cooperative ZEN-NOH, Mitsubishi Corp. to Form Agrichemical Joint Venture

The National Federation of Agricultural Cooperative Associations (ZEN-NOH) and Mitsubishi Corp. (MC) have announced the establishment of a new joint

Jim-DeLisi-and-Alex-Polinksy
Agrichemicals

Crop Protection Market Pressure Leading to Supplier Consolidation

The agricultural industry should be prepared for plenty of “domino effects” from moves within the crop protection sector.

Agrichemicals

Ag Disruptor to Watch: Crop Enhancement Has Unique Approach

CropCoat, the signature product of San Jose, California start-up Crop Enhancement, doesn’t quite fit into any of the typical crop protection categories.

Agrichemicals

A Big Week for the Future of Pesticide Authorization in the EU

The politically charged debate surrounding the future use of a number of key agricultural pesticides continues in Europe this week.

Agrichemicals

Elemica Partners with DHL Resilience360 to Better Mitigate Supply Chain Risk

Elemica, a leading Business Network for the process industries, and DHL Resilience360, a leading cloud-based supply chain risk management platform,

Agrichemicals

Brazil Agency: Bayer-Monsanto Tie-up can Hurt Competition

A unit of Brazil’s competition regulator Cade has said Bayer AG’s proposed takeover of Monsanto Co. could be detrimental to

Agrichemicals

Monsanto Sees Improved Glyphosate Prices, More Xtend Acres in ’18

Monsanto Co. announced higher fourth-quarter sales and a profit compared with a year ago, powered by higher sales of new corn and soybean seed and trait technologies.

Agrichemicals

AMVAC Completes Acquisition of OHP

American Vanguard Corp. (AMVAC) has completed the acquisition of OHP, Inc. a leading provider of technology based pesticide solutions for

Agrichemicals

Chempro’s Diego Taube Discusses Regulatory, Other Changes in Argentina

AgriBusiness Global sat down with Diego Taube, Managing Director, Chempro S.A., based in Buenos Aires, Argentina, following the AgriBusiness Global Trade Summit -- Americas to discuss changes impacting Argentina's agrichemical market.

Agrichemicals

Adama Finalizes Combination with Sanonda

The combined company’s shareholders approved the appointment of Yang Xingqiang, President of ChemChina, as the new Chairman of its Board, as well as the appointment of new directors.

Latest News

Agrichemicals

Monsanto Sues Arkansas Regulator Over Dicamba Ban

Monsanto is challenging the restrictions as Arkansas edges closer to adopting a temporary ban on dicamba herbicides for next year.

Agrichemicals

Summit Agro USA Launches New Corn Herbicide

SHIELDEX 400SC controls a wide range of broadleaf and grass weeds, including troublesome weeds such as tall waterhemp, Palmer amaranth, giant ragweed and giant foxtail.

Americas

Precision Agriculture to Improve Nutrient Use Efficiency in Brazil

The IPNI Brazil Symposium on Precision Agriculture was held in early October in Goiânia, Goiás, in central western Brazil.

Africa/Middle East

Syngenta, USAID Renew Global Collaboration to Improve Food Security

Renewed MOU to develop agriculture in Africa, Asia and Latin America.

Agrichemicals

U.S. Remains the Leading Crop Protection Market — For Now

Exclusive article by Dr. Bob Fairclough of Kleffmann Group.