Agrichemicals: The Politics of Channel Management

Editor’s note: This article was originally published on LinkedIn.

Many years ago, there used to be a notorious gang of clothing store thieves in the U.S. Their modus operandi was simple, but elegant. They used a long stick to remove large numbers of clothes from racks at once, thereby robbing the stores very quickly.

And one day, as the urban legend about this crime goes, the gang was caught when one store, at the suggestion of a cop, arranged its clothes with alternate hangers facing opposite directions (see the photograph below). This messed up the racking and the gang’s modus operandi and slowed down the thieves by forcing them to remove one hanger at a time.

Hangers
Photo Credits: Venkatesh Rao, Breaking Smart Newsletter: Politics of Productivity.

I love this story because it helps me illustrate a point I’ve come to appreciate in the last 10 months I’ve immersed in the agri-input industry:

Channel Management is Politics

Channel, at the end of the day, is about stakeholders vying to control the distribution. The fundamental reason why you should study the channel and its structures of distribution (Tier-1, Tier-2) deeply is not to simply get “organized” or “efficient” upto the last mile for its own sake, but to gain political control over the channel. Otherwise, you risk someone else taking control.

Allow me to spell the obvious truth.

There is no such thing as a “disorganized” channel. Every state of “organization” of channel is a means of control for somebody. And If you don’t know who that is, it probably isn’t you. As we build platforms which manage the channel through machine intelligence, it becomes all the more critical to understand who benefits from a particular structure of distribution.

That’s why I want to talk today about the politics of Channel Management. Shall we dive in?

In my last post, when I asked the question, “What influences the buying behavior of Indian farmers, when it comes to agri-inputs? ” and analyzed the critical importance of the Trade Channel in agri-input marketing, I got an interesting comment from Aashish Argade, Assistant Professor at Institute of Rural Marketing, Anand.

Aashish wrote,

“I spent about four years in the agri-inputs industry, and felt that there was no innovation in most of the business practices and processes…I find that agri-inputs is largely a product and/or price driven industry — successful companies either have new products, or they are low-priced. No efforts made to understand either the consumer or channel member more closely.”

Even if you disagree with his comments about understanding channel members, it’s a fact that we still have a long way to go to deeply understand the needs of the channel and the customers.

Think about it.

Why is it that the fundamental problems in the channel distribution haven’t been solved yet? Taslima Khan, in her story in Economic Times about agri-startups,summed it up well

“They(Agri Startups) are trying to disrupt the traditional channels of distribution—local retail shops and co-operatives closely associated with the farmers for ages but which have inherent challenges such as non-timely availability of products, non-transparent pricing and fake products.”

“Inherent challenges?”. Absolutely.

If you have been working hard for a decade attempting to solve these problems for world’s leading agrochemical companies, like we at iConcept do, you would know that we are talking about three intractable, entangled, messy problems.

By the way, do you know the trendiest, or the sexiest way to solve, or at least, claim to the world that you are solving these problems in 2018?

With due apologies to the utopians of the technology world, I am talking about Blockchain. Many believe that all roads to solve Traceability and fake products in agri-inputs end at Blockchain, despite its significant barriers of performance, scalability, security and energy-sustainability.

If you ask us, with a decade of experience, we’ve figured so far that nothing is more perfectly suited to Indian market conditions (or even other emerging markets, as our experience in Phillipines, Kenya, Malaysia & Indonesia attests) than the humble bar-coding solution. Sure, it may not look as cool as Block chain. However, cost-wise. efficiency-wise. flexibility-wise. It is the best appropriate Indian solution.

Here is the complete workflow of our m-PIN Bar-coding Solution approach, which has now become the industry norm in agrichemical industry.

This diagram is largely self-explanatory, and I don’t want to beat our own drums. But, I must tell you this.

In our experience so far, this dual approach of Inner mPIN and outer mPIN creates a positive feedback loop in addressing the challenges of Channel Inventory and Channel Loyalty together. It helps agrichemical and hybrid seeds companies address the mutually conflicting challenges of maximizing Product Availability and Working Capital Improvement.

Maximizing product availability is a no-brainer. But, what is working capital improvement? For most of you, this is everyday business. Allow me to spell the basics, for the uninitiated.

Working Capital Improvement:

When you are managing the channel, you strive to optimize the inventory data to determine the right safety stock levels. You set optimum inventory norms, lot sizes. You analyze slow-moving, obsolete inventory and balance stock across locations to ensure lower inventory carrying cost.

So far, so good.

Does this approach solve all the above three problems, once and forever?

You know the answer.

Perhaps, it helps to reflect on what Henry David Thoreau once said about technology.

“Technology is an improved means to an unimproved end”

What makes Channel management a political beast is exactly this realization.

These three problems are political by design. And to effectively work through these problems, you need a clarity of strategic vision, ability to experiment with structures of distribution (see the image below for an overview of structures) and implement them across your channel partners, and, last, but not the least, build effective business systems that can effectively control the channels in line with your strategic vision.

Structures-of-Distribution

If you are reading through the lines, the moral of the opening hanger-thieves story is very clear.

The moment you try to enforce uniformity across your channel edges near the last mile, you are exposing yourself to be attacked by your competitors.In fact, the weaker your channel strength is, the more varied your distribution structure should be (based on geography constraints) to maximize availability and resist control in the volatile political equation between the agri-input manufacturers and channel partners.

How do you play the art of channel management? How do you run better channel engagement programs? Do you experiment with different structures of distribution depending on your scaling goals? How have you transitioned from one structure to another structure of distribution?

Do you agree with my points? Would you like to share your candid feedback? Read. Debate. Argue. In the comments section.

P.S.: This post was inspired by this amazing newsletter I read on the Politics of Productivity.

Leave a Reply

Agrichemicals

Adjuvants

Clariant, Eastman Enter Distribution Agreement

Clariant, a world leader in specialty chemicals, and Eastman Chemical Company, a global advanced materials and specialty additives company, announced

Agrichemicals

What Does a Traceability Software Product Do in Agribusiness?

Editor’s note: This article was originally published on LinkedIn. I’ve been traveling over the last one week, on-boarding our first large

Agrichemicals

University of Utah Recognizes Aqua-Yield/Nano Institute Partnership in New Annual Report

In a newly-published annual report, the University of Utah’s Center for Technology & Venture Commercialization (TVC) touts the first-of-its-kind collaboration

Corn closeup
Herbicides

Bayer Posts More Than 300 Glyphosate Safety Studies Online

Today, Bayer marks the first anniversary of its Transparency Initiative, designed to enhance trust in the science behind crop protection

Agrichemicals

UPL Mauritius to Acquire Bioquim Group

UPL Mauritius, a subsidiary of UPL, India is set to acquire 100% shares of Bioquim Group which includes companies based

Parry-lab
Agrichemicals

Crop Protection: How to Lead Innovation in R&D Teams (Part 5)

Editor’s note: This is the fifth of seven articles in a series on Strategic R&D Management in AgChem and BioScience

Aphids Cotton
Agrichemicals

Nichino America Gets EPA Approval for Insecticide

PQZ insecticide from Nichino America, Inc. has been granted a U.S. EPA label expansion for food crop use, the company

Agrichemicals

Crystal Crop Protection Acquires Three Syngenta Brands

New Delhi-headquartered Crystal Crop Protection, a firm backed by private equity firm Everstone Capital, has acquired three insecticide and fungicide

Agrichemicals

Bayer to Offer Access to Glyphosate Studies

Bayer will soon include safety study summaries of glyphosate on its dedicated transparency platform. This next step will mark the first

Agrichemicals

What to Expect for U.S. Dicamba Use in 2019

Long-awaited news from U.S. Environmental Protection Agency on its decision to extend the registration for the new dicamba technologies arrived Halloween

Agrichemicals

Bayer: Study Shows its Soybeans Reduce Environmental Impact

Results from a five-year peer-reviewed study on Intacta RR2 PRO™ soybeans planted in South America were recently published, indicating that

Jay-Vroom-Covers-featured-image
Agrichemicals

A Salute to Retired CropLife America President Jay Vroom

Editor’s note: It goes without saying that crop protection manufacturing is a central point of interest to readers of this

US-China-Trade-War
Agrichemicals

Expect Herbicide Price Hikes in 2019

Herbicide price hikes across the board are an inevitability for 2019, as the entire U.S. ag community deals with a

Agrichemicals

Corteva to Launch New Fungicide, Starting in Asia Pacific

Corteva Agriscience announced Adavelt active as the new brand name for a novel fungicide that will offer farmers curative and

wheat-field
Agrichemicals

Albaugh Discusses 2018 Trials of CoAXium Wheat System

Albaugh announced that the CoAXium Wheat Production System driven by Aggressor herbicide exceeded expectations in 2018 performance evaluation trials, demonstrating

Agrichemicals

FMC Launches Insecticide/Fungicide

FMC Corp. has launched Ethos 3D insecticide/fungicide, formulated specifically for the novel 3RIVE 3D in-furrow application system that converts traditional

Corn-field
Herbicides

The U.S. Battle over Glyphosate Has ‘Old World’ Roots

Although it’s been in use since 1974, glyphosate has come under intense attack here in the U.S. just recently, writes

Kenya-Agriculture
Africa/Middle East

Kenya’s Crop Protection Industry Fears ‘Dire Consequences’ of New Pesticides Tax

The agrichemcials industry in Kenya is up in arms over a decision by the government to impose a 16% value-added

Agrichemicals

U.S. EPA Renews Dicamba Label, with New Restrictions

Long-awaited news from U.S. EPA came on the evening of Oct. 31 that it has decided to renew the label

Latest News

Asia

India: Enabling Modern Agriculture Through IoT

Since the first green revolution in the 1960s that radically transformed the face of Indian agriculture, the sector has consistently

Asia

Reuters: Trump Greenlights Next Round of Farm Payments in China Trade War

The Trump administration will move forward with plans to distribute a second round of payments to farmers caught in the

Markets

AgriBusinessGlobal.com: Top 10 Stories from 2018

What a year it’s been for the global agribusiness industry. While the mergers and acquisitions once again dominated headlines in

Trade Summit

Three Things We Learned at Trade Summit Southeast Asia

Since 2006 AgriBusiness Global™ (ABG) has hosted Trade Summits in all corners of the world in an effort to empower

Asia

AgFunder Releases India AgriFood Startup Investing Report

AgFunder has released the inaugural India AgriFood Startup Investing Report in collaboration with its report partner Omnivore. In this five-year