Biorational Processes in Biopesticide Discovery and Development

Agchem companies are expanding their biopesticide R&D and portfolios, driven by stricter pesticide regulatory requirements, consumer awareness regarding hazards caused by chemical pesticides, and the phasing out of conventional toxic pesticides.

One of the critical challenges to this process is the discovery and development of biopesticidal candidates.

Biopesticide discovery and development follows a biorational process of scouting/discovery and screening over lead development, formulation, and scale-up, to application development, manufacturing, and commercial introduction.

Biorational process: the design and implementation of biopesticide discovery and development processes through screening (and the conservation of) specific biological effects (including pest and pathogen control, crop stress alleviation, and enhanced plant resilience) against the pathogens and pests they are intended to control.

Figure 1: Biopesticide Discovery & Development Processes.

Biopesticide Scouting

Biopesticide scouting: the identification of biopesticidally-active natural candidate species — includes observation in the field (the identification of plants showing exceptional natural growth or pest-defense responses) as well as ethnobotanical, anatomical, and physiological indicators to identify potential candidates.

Ethnobotany: the scientific study of traditional knowledge and customs regarding plants and their uses.

Bioinsecticide Discovery

Predating the development of synthetic pesticides during and after WWII, the ethnobotany of plant-derived pesticides — primarily insecticides — dates back at least two thousand years to Asia and the Mediterranean regions. In Europe and North America, plant-derived pesticides date back more than 150 years.

One of the most-cited ethnobotanical bioinsecticide examples is the use of plants of the genus Pyrethrum (now classified as Chrysanthemum or Tanacetum) in insecticide preparations, dating back to Persia about 400 B.C. Brought to Europe in the early 19th century, dried and ground flowers of Dalmatian chrysanthemum (Tanacetum cinerariaefolium) were used to control body lice during the Napoleonic Wars. Today, pyrethrum and its pyrethroid synthetic analogues are among the most widely-used biological and conventional insecticides.

Neem (Azadirachta indica) is an evergreen tree native to the Indian sub-continent, used for thousands of years against household and storage pests, as well as pests related to field crops, and currently attracting global attention due to its potential as a commercial biopesticide.

Biofungicide Discovery

In 1988, East German scientists tasked with the production of spores of the fungal plant pathogen, Sclerotinia trifoliorum, discovered that a fungal parasite inhibited the pathogen. Recognizing its potential as a natural pesticide process, C. minitans was successfully developed as a commercial biopesticide by its discoverers, following the reunification of Germany.

The discovery that non-pathogenic microbes can induce plant defense responses is undoubtedly not new. My grandfather — famous for his roses which never seemed to be afflicted by mildew — would follow his grandfather’s example, and spray yeast-rich beer dregs over his roses.

We now understand that the exposure of fungal yeast cells to plant leaves leads to the induction of plant defense responses, as the plants believe themselves to be under invasion by a potential fungal pathogen.

The EU pesticides database for Basic Substances (substances with a low toxicity profile not predominantly used for plant protection purposes but which could be useful in plant protection) includes Beer as one of the only 18 approved substances, while one of only 10 approved Low-risk Active Substances is Brewer’s Yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) — approved for use as a fungicide.

In a more recent example, Burkina Faso farmers are — together with researchers at Copenhagen University — testing the effects of a local plant (False Daisy, Eclipta alba) discovered to contain antifungal compounds, to develop inexpensive plant extracts capable of replacing synthetic fungicides.

Biofungicide discovery is currently being driven using biotech tools, including the monitoring of defense-related gene expression, pathogenesis-related proteins, bioinformatics (the collection, classification, storage, and analysis of biochemical and biological information using computers), and genomic analysis.

Bioherbicide Discovery

Bioherbicide discovery typically involves the study of biochemical processes specific to plants, including photosynthesis, amino acid biosynthesis, chlorophyll and carotenoid biosynthesis, and growth regulation (phytohormones).

Our growing understanding of these plant-specific processes is facilitating the identification of new herbicides’ sites of action, permitting the screening and development of bioherbicidally active metabolites with low mammalian toxicity, shorter environmental persistence, and novel target specificity.

Biopesticide Lead Development

In biopesticide lead development, microbes isolated from soil and plant microbiomes associated with plants showing exceptional growth or natural pest-defense responses are sequenced and compared against a database of known pathogens. Matches are discarded, while the remainder transition to bioassay screening to identify biostimulatory or biopesticidal effects.

Potential leads are analyzed and characterized to ensure the absence of toxins, before embarking on a process of lab and field testing, fermentation process development, formulation, and scale-up.

Each of the steps in this process of biorational development are subject to considerable challenges, but for biological pesticide development the transition from lab to field testing is one of the most crucial. The correlation between a greenhouse result and a field result is not necessarily a given.

This is in part due to the complexity of biotic and abiotic factors affecting microbial characteristics, and the transient formulation stability of naturally-derived metabolites and microbes. The latter factor — rapid degradation by ultraviolet light, oxygen, and microbial activity — contributes to shorter environmental persistence, a key factor driving the acceptance of biopesticides.

For conventional chemistries, development times can be three times longer than for biological crop protection development, while expenses may be as much as 10 times greater.

Figure 2: Innovation costs and timelines for conventional and biological crop protection development (from: FMC – Investor Relations Solutions, 2015).

Industry figures suggest that the R&D process for a novel synthetic pesticide costs more than 250 million USD and requires 10 years of development, while the development of a biopesticide may cost 25 million USD and require three years of development.
Because of these differences, agbio start-ups and other local, innovative companies have created a robust and competitive environment for biopesticide discovery and development, and the current wave of acquisitions, collaboration, and licensing agreements with the incumbent agchem industry bear witness to an ongoing symbiosis in the field of biopesticide R&D.

Thanks for reading. Please feel free to read and share my other articles.

For more information, visit BioScience Solutions, which contributes to the development of sustainable crop protection solutions by providing independent strategic R&D management and scientific support to agchem and biosolutions businesses developing science-based products.

Leave a Reply



FMC Launches Insecticide/Fungicide

FMC Corp. has launched Ethos 3D insecticide/fungicide, formulated specifically for the novel 3RIVE 3D in-furrow application system that converts traditional


Marrone in Distribution Deal with Input Supplier in Turkey

Marrone Bio Innovations, Inc., a leading global provider of bio-based pest management and plant health products, announced that it has


How the Biopesticide and SMART-TECH Industries Create a “Blue Ocean” of Uncontested Crop Protection Market Space (Part 4)

Editor’s note: This is the fourth of seven articles in a series on Strategic R&D Management in AgChem and BioScience


Bayer Biological Product Registered in France

Bayer said its Serenade ASO fungicide/bactericide has received registration in France for foliar and soil applications on a wide range


Bayer Seeking Biologicals Partnerships

Bayer says it is seeking partners as it looks to increase its presence in the biologicals market. The company is

Wheat field

How ‘Softer Chemistry’ in Crop Protection Addresses Increased Emphasis on Safety

With the recent implementation of the Food Safety Modernization Act, a spotlight is now being shone on the need for

Pam Marrone

Marrone Enters Distribution Partnership in Vietnam, Cambodia

Key factors driving the rapid adoption of biologicals in Vietnam include pesticide residue problems in agro-products for local consumption, new requirements for Maximum Residue Levels on agro-products imported to the EU and U.S., and a growing number of banned pesticides.


STK REGEV Biofungicide Now Registered in Argentina

STK bio-ag technologies, the innovative Israeli-based leader in bio-ag technologies for sustainable crop protection and aquaculture, has announced its ‘hybrid’


BioConsortia Promotes Dr. Hong Zhu to Sr. VP of Research and Development

BioConsortia, Inc., innovator of microbial solutions for natural plant trait enhancement and yield improvement, has promoted Dr. Hong Zhu to


Marrone Bio Innovations Submits Novel Bioherbicide for EPA Approval

Marrone Bio Innovations, Inc. (MBI), a leading provider of bio-based pest management and plant health products for the agriculture, turf


PepsiCo in Deal with Arysta LifeScience Chile on Biological Products

Under the agreement, the select group of Chilean potato farmers that supplies PepsiCo on an exclusive basis will use the solutions from the Arysta LifeScience Pronutiva program, which combines traditional crop protection inputs with biological solutions.


3 Questions with BioTecnologie BT’s Piffanelli on EU Regulatory Environment

BioTecnologie BT is a Perugia, Italy-based contract research organization (CRO) specialized in the regulatory testing of biopesticides and biostimulants.


Corbion CEO Tjerk de Ruiter Appointed as New EuropaBio Chairman

EuropaBio’s Executive Board and General Assembly of Members confirmed the appointment of Tjerk de Ruiter as Chairman of the association.


FaunaSmart, BioScience Solutions Form Innovative Collaboration in Crop Protection

FaunaSmart and BioScience Solutions have announced a cooperation within strategic business development and innovation strategies in crop protection. Harry Teicher,


FMC, Chr. Hansen Extend Collaboration on Natural Crop Protection

FMC Corp. and Chr. Hansen have announced a five-year extension of their collaboration to develop and commercialize natural solutions for the agricultural industry.


Tradecorp Acquires Spain’s Idai Nature

Idai Nature is currently present in 35 countries and has posted annual growth of more than 30% in recent years. The company’s consolidated revenues amount to 16 million euros.


A (Surprisingly Long) Biopesticide Timeline

The application of biopesticides in plant protection is certainly not a new innovation. A few examples are presented in the


Marrone Bio Innovations Names Hammill as Chief Commercial Officer

Most recently, Hammill was Chief Operating Officer at Pivot Bio, a startup company.


Biopesticides: Assessing the Opportunities and Challenges in R&D, Formulation

Editor’s note: Dr. Harry Teicher, an independent Strategic R&D consultant with over 20-plus years of AgChem and BioScience R&D Management

Latest News

Industry News

Cibus Files Registration Statement for Proposed Initial Public Offering

Cibus Ltd., a leader in advanced plant-breeding technologies, has publicly filed a registration statement on Form S-1 with the U.S.


What to Expect for U.S. Dicamba Use in 2019

Long-awaited news from U.S. Environmental Protection Agency on its decision to extend the registration for the new dicamba technologies arrived Halloween


Report: Farming in 20% of Indian Districts Threatened by Climate Change

Crops, plantations, even livestock in 151 districts, or slightly more than one-fifth of the total districts in India, are susceptible


Bayer: Study Shows its Soybeans Reduce Environmental Impact

Results from a five-year peer-reviewed study on Intacta RR2 PRO™ soybeans planted in South America were recently published, indicating that


A Salute to Retired CropLife America President Jay Vroom

Editor’s note: It goes without saying that crop protection manufacturing is a central point of interest to readers of this