The End of Glyphosate

David Frabotta
David P. Frabotta

HERE’S A PREDICTION: The crop protection industry’s $6-billion blockbuster will be half of its current value in 10 years, and Monsanto’s market-leading Roundup brand will be on the auction block in a matter of years, if not months.

As Bayer moves forward with its $66-billion acquisition of Monsanto, the German company will have some tough decisions to make about its product portfolio. Specifically, many analysts and industry sources expect regulators will require the new agriculture behemoth to divest its significant herbicide market share. That means it will need to cho
ose between keeping Monsanto’s glyphosate position or its own glufosinate brand, Liberty.

Looking at market developments, this is an easy choice: Bayer will keep glufosinate and sell its positions in glyphosate. Here are the reasons:
• Regulatory pressure: Glyphosate is the most widely used AI in crop protection, but its share is shrinking due to regulatory scrutiny. The EU re-approved the use of glyphosate through 2017 just two days before its scheduled expiry. The unusual 18-month re-approval is seen by many as a way for member states to build a case to limit or ban its further use. Brazil, another huge glyphosate market, has increasingly shown a tendency to an EU-style hazard-based system, and many regulatory observers fear the U.S. may follow suit.
• Changing seed products: Glyphosate-dependent Roundup Ready seeds are susceptible to an almost-inevitable loss in market share as new seed traits are poised for mainstream commercialization in 2017. Stacked traits that are resistant to glufosinate, dicamba, and 2,4-D will steal planted area away from the ruling Roundup Ready technology. Additionally, advances in gene editing and RNAi will continue to change the GMO dynamic around the world.
• Overproduction: Competition is fierce in the glyphosate market, which has driven profits into the ground for years. Monsanto’s Q4 earnings report warns of continued “pricing headwinds” coupled with lower demand. Overproduction has commodified glyphosate to a point where prices have remained low for five years, and there is no firming in sight. Conversely, just three Chinese companies — Jiangsu Sevencontinent, Hebei Veyong, and Sichuan Lier — were aggressively exporting glufosinate in 2015. Although more companies are producing glufosinate and the industry seems poised to repeat the mistake it made by overproducing glyphosate, glufosinate intermediates appear to be in shorter supply and therefore controllable, giving more power to large producers.
• Antitrust: When announcing the Monsanto deal, Bayer executives declined to make any assumptions about what regulators would require the combined company to divest to meet approval. Many in the industry surmise that glyphosate, combined with the fast-growing $2-billion glufosinate market, is too much of the herbicide market to remain intact.
• Data and R&D: Bayer executives made clear their interest in precision farming and the allure of Climate Corporation as part of this deal (see cover story). Just as Monsanto has done, Bayer looks to be re-adjusting the focus of its portfolio to emphasize data-based farming and next-generation seed technologies over traditional chemistries.
With Bayer’s acquisition of AgraQuest, Monsanto’s BioAg Alliance with Novozymes, and the significant investments both companies have made into precision farming and seed technologies, the combined company appears ready for a life without glyphosate.
All that being said, some companies stand to make significant revenues in the near-term on glyphosate as companies divest their interests. It’s still the world’s most widely used AI, and some notable brands will become available. Roundup could be one of them.

Contact Dave: dpfrabotta@meistermedia.com

Topics: , , , , , ,

Agrichemicals

Agrichemicals

European Commission Clears DuPont Deals Linked to Dow Merger

The European Commission has conditionally approved the sale by DuPont of part of its crop protection business to FMC Corp.

Werner Baumann and Hugh Grant
Agrichemicals

Bayer CEO Expects EU Nod for Monsanto Deal After Extended Probe

Bayer AG’s CEO said he expects its $66 billion combination with Monsanto Co. to close by the end of the year

Herbicides

Engage Agro Herbicide Granted for Emergency Use in Mint

Engage Agro, a member of the Belchim Group, has announced that Tough 5EC Herbicide (Pyridate) has been granted a Section

Agrichemicals

Huntsman-Clariant Merger Remains on Track

Clariant and Huntsman Corp. have presented a first update on the planned merger of equals to keep their shareholders informed.

Agrichemicals

Syngenta Reports 2017 Half-Year Results

Innovation and productivity savings have partially offset weak market conditions for Syngenta in the first half of 2017. The company

Agrichemicals

Bayer-Monsanto Merger Will Grow, Not Stifle, Innovation in Agriculture

Bayer’s acquisition of Monsanto has some critics concerned that the merger would deter innovation in the agricultural sector and impact

Agrichemicals

DuPont Gets Boost From Farmers With Dow Merger Set to Close

DuPont Co. got a boost from U.S. farmers as it closes in on the historic $75 billion merger with Dow

Agrichemicals

Dow Executive Named New CEO at Lindsay Corp.

Lindsay Corp. has  announced the appointment of Timothy Hassinger as president and CEO and a member of its board of

Agrichemicals

Complexity in Agriculture: The Rise (and Fall?) of Monsanto

Sometimes it seems as if the ag world is changing so fast that we can barely keep up with it

Agrichemicals

ChemChina Participation in Syngenta Exceeds 98% Threshold

Following the purchase of additional Syngenta shares, ChemChina’s participation in Syngenta has exceeded 98% of Syngenta’s share capital. As a

Agrichemicals

As Drift Complaints Snowball, Tennessee Sets New Dicamba Rules

While stopping short of a ban, Tennessee sets stricter application parameters for the herbicide.

Agrichemicals

BASF Responds to Dicamba Restrictions in Arkansas, Missouri

"Recent actions taken in Arkansas and Missouri to ban or restrict the use of dicamba herbicides, including BASF’s Engenia, deprive farmers of the one option that has proven effective in controlling this worrisome, yield-robbing issue."

Agrichemicals

China Launches Anti-Dumping Probe on India Imports

China's Weifang Runnong Chemical claims that India exported MPB at a lower price than the normal value, which has led to continuous price decreases in China’s domestic market.

Agrichemicals

Dow to Sell Part of Corn Seed Business to CITIC Agri Fund

Transaction marks continued progress in proposed Dow and DuPont transaction.

Agrichemicals

Bayer, Netafirm Develop New Smart Irrigation Approach

Market launch is planned in Mexico by the end of 2017.

Africa/Middle East

South Africa Conditionally Approves Dow, DuPont Merger

The decision follows recent conditional approvals from global antitrust authorities in Canada and Mexico and from the U.S. Department of Justice on June 15.

Agrichemicals

Insecticide Seed Treatment Market to Grow to $5.04 Billion by 2022

Neonicotinoids are projected to be the fastest-growing chemical sub-type between 2017 and 2022.

Agrichemicals

CropLife America: States’ Decisions on Dicamba Premature

CropLife America issued the following statement on July 10: Over the last couple weeks, both Missouri and Arkansas state governments

Agrichemicals

China’s Exports Drop in 2016

The U.S. and Brazil remain major markets for China’s crop protection exports.

Latest News

Agrichemicals

European Commission Clears DuPont Deals Linked to Dow Merger

The European Commission has conditionally approved the sale by DuPont of part of its crop protection business to FMC Corp.

Agrichemicals

Bayer CEO Expects EU Nod for Monsanto Deal After Extended Probe

Bayer AG’s CEO said he expects its $66 billion combination with Monsanto Co. to close by the end of the year

Herbicides

Engage Agro Herbicide Granted for Emergency Use in Mint

Engage Agro, a member of the Belchim Group, has announced that Tough 5EC Herbicide (Pyridate) has been granted a Section

Biostimulants

Valagro Reaches Agreement with Syngenta to Supply Biostimulants for Seed Treatment

Valagro, a leader in the production and marketing of biostimulants and specialty nutrients, has signed an agreement with Syngenta, a

Agrichemicals

Huntsman-Clariant Merger Remains on Track

Clariant and Huntsman Corp. have presented a first update on the planned merger of equals to keep their shareholders informed.