Opinion: Rethinking Sustainability in Modern Agriculture

The future need for sustainable agriculture is huge. With an already enormous world population that is rapidly growing, the future of sustainable agriculture, to a large degree, will revolve around yield levels. We need to be able to produce a lot of healthy, nutritious food in a sustainable way that can continue over generations.

There are good reasons for optimism from an agricultural perspective. Modern agriculture, with its future potentials, is one of the most innovative fields of our time. New ideas of producing crops in resource-efficient ways consistently come to light and are implemented. The combination of game-changing concepts, tools, and technology seem to stand a good chance of overcoming future challenges. The focus on products that can help this happen is vital toward that end. Fertilizers and inputs are among the most central of these products.

Of course, there are challenges. One is to protect the environment from adverse effects and to maintain ecosystem functioning. Another is to handle the concerns for greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuels.

Many experts argue that we must minimize environmental impact. This seems to be the consensus among the public as well, at least in the Western world. This is deeply problematic because it is not driven by a rational concern for mankind or the environment. Minimized environmental impact cannot, in and of itself, be the main goal. The main goal must be human flourishing and minimized human suffering. Of course, environmental concerns are important aspects that must be weighed when striving toward that goal. But in the end they are only factors in a bigger picture. In other words the environmental goal must be as environmentally friendly as possible when working toward human flourishing.

In real life there are no absolute solutions, only trade-offs. When evaluating a practice, one cannot simply compare it to a utopic scenario in which there are no bad effects. Any meaningful, serious, and realistic evaluation must be based on relevant comparisons. First, the negative side effects must be compared to the positive main effects. When the sum of all effects is a net positive, the product or practice is worthwhile. Second, regardless of what one thinks about a practice or product, we can only compare it to the alternatives we have at hand. And the comparison must be holistic and fair; pros are compared with pros, and cons with cons.

In some cases there are no viable options at hand, in which case we must stick to what we’ve got, whether we like it or not, until we have viable options. That is the case with fossil fuels.

This leads to the question of how we should define the concept of sustainable agriculture altogether. Most people today think of non-conventional or organic farming when they hear the word sustainable. I think this is mainly due to the ideological discourse in the debate.

So, let’s look at a couple of facts about fertilizers, as they have significant bearing on the concept of sustainability:

  • Modern fertilizers enable us to feed the world; organic fertilizers simply can’t do that. Even if we were to close that cycle, the world simply doesn’t contain enough organic fertilizers to produce a sufficient amount of food for a growing population.
  • Modern fertilizers are more environmentally friendly than organic ones. The levels of nutrient leaching are much worse for organic fertilizers.
  • Modern fertilizers can be used with extreme precision and accuracy to maximize resource use efficiency, while organic fertilizers cannot.

How then can the use of modern commercial fertilizers be considered unsustainable by so many people? I think there are two answers to this:

First, we must realize that a lot of people who oppose the use of modern fertilizers are simply ignorant. Worse, some facts are unpopular simply because they make no good fit in the ideology of modern environmentalism. The second reason has to do with how we view sustainability. It has nothing to do with labels. The word is a philosophical term that needs to be well defined. Sustainable agriculture simply means — enough food for humanity, from a production system that can be perpetuated, in which the benefits exceed the disadvantages. Therefore, our job is to push facts and to make known that sustainable agriculture is about human flourishing and the prevention of human suffering for generations to come.

Leave a Reply

Markets

Agrichemicals

What to Expect for U.S. Dicamba Use in 2019

Long-awaited news from U.S. Environmental Protection Agency on its decision to extend the registration for the new dicamba technologies arrived Halloween

India-farmers
Asia

Report: Farming in 20% of Indian Districts Threatened by Climate Change

Crops, plantations, even livestock in 151 districts, or slightly more than one-fifth of the total districts in India, are susceptible

Agrichemicals

Bayer: Study Shows its Soybeans Reduce Environmental Impact

Results from a five-year peer-reviewed study on Intacta RR2 PRO™ soybeans planted in South America were recently published, indicating that

Americas

Mexico: Ripe for Growth in High-Value Horticulture Crops

Editor’s Note: Eric Viramontes is Executive Director of Meister Media Worldwide Mexico, based in Guadalajara. Here he provides an overview

Agrichemicals

Corteva to Launch New Fungicide, Starting in Asia Pacific

Corteva Agriscience announced Adavelt active as the new brand name for a novel fungicide that will offer farmers curative and

wheat-field
Agrichemicals

Albaugh Discusses 2018 Trials of CoAXium Wheat System

Albaugh announced that the CoAXium Wheat Production System driven by Aggressor herbicide exceeded expectations in 2018 performance evaluation trials, demonstrating

Africa/Middle East

20,000 Ethiopian Smallholders Targeted with Climate Smart Technology

CTA together with Farm Africa has launched a new project to promote the resilience of smallholder farmers against climate change

Asia

Marrone in Distribution Deal with Input Supplier in Turkey

Marrone Bio Innovations, Inc., a leading global provider of bio-based pest management and plant health products, announced that it has

Americas

Russia, Brazil Use Precision Ag Platform in Unexpected Ways

“For the first time ever, farmers are seeing that our imagery is as good as walking in the field. Farmers

Biopesticides

How the Biopesticide and SMART-TECH Industries Create a “Blue Ocean” of Uncontested Crop Protection Market Space (Part 4)

Editor’s note: This is the fourth of seven articles in a series on Strategic R&D Management in AgChem and BioScience

Lab
Africa/Middle East

Bayer-Monsanto Merger Ramps Up Technological Transformation in Africa

Farmers in Africa are on the cusp of benefiting from cutting-edge innovations that will catapult growth of the agricultural sector

Markets

Two Brief Lessons for Agri-Input Retailing from Amazon Prime

Editor’s note: This article was originally published on LinkedIn. Let me start with a trivia question. Can you guess the

Kenya-Agriculture
Africa/Middle East

Kenya’s Crop Protection Industry Fears ‘Dire Consequences’ of New Pesticides Tax

The agrichemcials industry in Kenya is up in arms over a decision by the government to impose a 16% value-added

Agrichemicals

ADAMA Hit by Drought in Europe, Higher Sourcing Costs

Shortage in certain raw materials and intermediates, mostly owing to increased environmental focus in China, led to higher procurement costs

Phillips-F-Richard
Americas

U.S.-China Trade Forum Held Amid Trade Disputes

U.S.-China Agriculture Food Trade Forum was held Thursday in the western U.S. state of California, focusing on the promotion of

Cargo-of-Brazilian-soy-Photo-VCG
Americas

Opinion: Brazil’s Bolsonaro Can’t Afford to Upset Ties with China

Brazil’s far-right ex-army captain Jair Bolsonaro rode a wave of voter rage to the presidency on Sunday, writes CGTN’s Liu

Chilean-Farmland
Americas

Chilean Delegation Seeks Agricultural Collaboration with India

A high level agricultural Chilean delegation is arriving on Monday in India to talk about the new strategic guidelines of

Agrichemicals

Belchim Crop Protection: Reevaluating Sourcing

Belchim Crop Protection began hearing rumblings about China’s crackdown on manufacturers violating environmental regulations and potential supply disruptions in late

Americas

Syngenta to Open Seeds Hub in Chicago

Syngenta announced it will establish a major Global and North America Seeds office in the western suburbs of Chicago. Approximately

Latest News

Biopesticides

Terramera Gets EPA Approval for Biocontrol Product

Terramera announced the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency approved registration of its novel, broad-spectrum agricultural insect, fungal disease, and mite control

Industry News

Cibus Files Registration Statement for Proposed Initial Public Offering

Cibus Ltd., a leader in advanced plant-breeding technologies, has publicly filed a registration statement on Form S-1 with the U.S.

Agrichemicals

What to Expect for U.S. Dicamba Use in 2019

Long-awaited news from U.S. Environmental Protection Agency on its decision to extend the registration for the new dicamba technologies arrived Halloween

Asia

Report: Farming in 20% of Indian Districts Threatened by Climate Change

Crops, plantations, even livestock in 151 districts, or slightly more than one-fifth of the total districts in India, are susceptible

Agrichemicals

Bayer: Study Shows its Soybeans Reduce Environmental Impact

Results from a five-year peer-reviewed study on Intacta RR2 PRO™ soybeans planted in South America were recently published, indicating that