Small Steps Are the Way for Sulphur Mills

Bimal Shah

While China’s industry deals with a difficult transformation, and India eyes the opportunity, the nuances of the situation can’t be overlooked. India is grappling with its own set of challenges, reminds Bimal Shah, Director of Mumbai-based Sulphur Mills Limited.

“India’s infrastructure is slower and movement takes time. Regulatory sometimes takes more time,” Shah says.

There is a concern that China could reverse course on its environmental crackdown, leaving India with overcapacity, and so India must be conservative. This cautious outlook is also rooted in a concern that overall use of synthetic chemistries will go down while biological-based products surge, he says.

While China could not go back to its former production ways overnight, “nor should India try something new overnight,” Shah said at the company’s meeting room at the AgriBusiness Global Trade Summit on Aug. 2. “India is not ready also – there is some dependence on backward integration, and a lot of intermediates still come out of China. It’s a good chance for India to buckle up and get the manufacturing and the backward integration into intermediates set-ups.”

“I see a good next five years, at least, to set the pace for the manufacturing in India. That is not for all raw materials from China, but 40% to 50% of raw materials I think is a fair number. Now, how fast it happens, how quick our infrastructure comes, and how fast the regulatory works – all of that is another thing.”

With this and other factors in mind, Sulphur Mills has chosen to take a more conservative approach to expansion than some of its competitors (the UPL-Arysta deal comes to mind).

“We were dependent on China for active ingredients, and one baby step we took was investing in our own facilities to add manufacturing of AIs and intermediates,” Shah says, “not only for ourselves but whatever we can part with also. But it’s more for internal consumption, and to be less dependent on other active and intermediate manufacturers and other companies in China,” he explains.

“Currently we have some basic older chemistries like chlorpyrifos, thiamethoxam, metrabuzin, and pendimethalin. We have additional land and are expanding the capacities of existing products or chain chemistries, which is something we feel that could be missing based on this whole environmental issue. We are looking at some new chemistries that are just coming off patent and deciding on new products and investments, which we should have more clear in the next two to three years.”

Sulphur Mills is also making more headway in formulation technology – it is India’s largest manufacturer of microencapsulations. The company has an R&D lab and develops and markets its own proprietary formulations, as well as for multinationals.

“We are looking for some forward integration for distribution, because more of our products require a lot of training — for the person who is trying to sell it, distribution who is going to use it, and the farmer who is going to apply it. We need to be able to show why the product is better than what is already being used,” he says, adding, “per kilo, it’s expensive, but per hectare it’s cheaper — if that isn’t explained right, then no matter if you have gold in your product.”

Shah on the uncertainty about the future:
“We see certain molecules disappearing too, such as some pyrethroids, because certain intermediates and chemicals that are available in China may not be available in other countries. We don’t know what is going to happen to those chemistries.

“India should not only be building in -1 but in -2, -3, -4 to be really backward integrated because otherwise there is still dependence. Lesser dependence is always good because there is so much uncertainty in China — the situation can change in five minutes. Forget a day.”

On Costs and Pricing:
“There is still a lot of dependency on China, but it needs to be more regulated. It can’t be just anybody making anything overnight without any policy or environmental conditions not looked at, so hence the cost is less. The Chinese government gives 11% to 13% as rebate on exports — that’s also a benefit for them. Of course, the cost is going to be less,” he continues.

“At the end of day, if you don’t have a cost of producing it the right way, you are cheaper. India has had a concern for the environment from the beginning, so the plants are expensive to run compared to China.

“Now China will go through the same things and have the same restrictions — the cost is going to increase. Because of the economy of scale and size of plants in China, there will be differences in pricing (with India) of course, but it won’t be drastic as earlier.”

On Investing in India:
“Even multinationals are having problems because they’ve set up a lot of their backward bases in China, and now they’re concerned. In fact, even Chinese companies are concerned that, ‘We don’t get to start here, so why don’t we invest in Indian companies and make something there?’ The laws are there, they are more stringent from the beginning and cost more, but you make the product, at least, rather than zero. In China, they are saying, ‘Go to Mongolia’ and do this and do that, and it’s not working well.

“That uncertainty in dealing with China — whether there is an environmental concern or something else — is always going to be there. That’s one thing with the Indian manufacturing base: the reliability of information and if something happens it is more long-term and stable. In this year or next year, too, if you’re buying something, you never know if your contract is going to be agreed, your timeline agreed, so there are a lot of issues. I think India has the benefit of reliability and sustainability. A lot of multinationals are now investing in India to manufacture their AIs or intermediates.”

Topics: , ,

Leave a Reply



What to Do If You Have Products Subject to New U.S. Tariffs

The new retaliation lists hit almost every product that the Chinese import from the U.S.


Trump Tariffs on Chinese Imports to Begin Sept. 24

Starting Jan. 1, 2019, the level of the additional tariffs will increase to 25 percent.

Pam Marrone

Marrone Enters Distribution Partnership in Vietnam, Cambodia

Key factors driving the rapid adoption of biologicals in Vietnam include pesticide residue problems in agro-products for local consumption, new requirements for Maximum Residue Levels on agro-products imported to the EU and U.S., and a growing number of banned pesticides.

vietnam flag

Vietnamese Government Encouraged to Embrace Ag Innovation

"We call on the government to ensure that crop protection tools are properly assessed through a consistent, scientifically rigorous process in line with internationally accepted methods and standards."


Cargill Looks to Crop Enhancement Inc. in Indonesia

Indonesian cocoa growers in Cargill’s extensive network are eager to expand their use of this effective, farmer-friendly solution that reduces the need for synthetic pesticides.

Flag of China

Agriculture in the U.S. and China: The Present and the Future

In part because of current events involving a high-profile trade dispute, agriculture in the U.S. and China has been thrown


A Unique Advantage for Anupam Rasayan India Ltd.

Gujarat-based Anupam Rasayan is working its status as a custom manufacturer that operates independently of Chinese materials to its maximum advantage.


Hedge Hurts ADAMA Profit, While Sales Rise

The past two quarters have seen the beginnings of a recovery in demand for crop protection products in many markets, despite ongoing low soft commodity prices and farmer income.


Sourcing Agchem from China: An Outlook that Demands Strategic Planning

C S Liew, Pacific Agriscience Pte Ltd, Singapore, examines the repercussions of the Chinese environmental crackdown and sourcing at the 2018 Trade Summit held in Phoenix, Arizona.


Is India a Future Manufacturing Hub for Agrichemicals?

The changing scenario in global trade has made a significant impact on agrichemical business in India. Although the country is


India’s Hemani Industries Forges New Partnerships

“I think customers are tired of having so much inconsistency in supply. There’s a mystery of what’s going to be available and what’s not, so they want to go into a partnership so they’re assured of supplies, and hopefully, prices.”


Tariff Wars Promise New Pain for Agriculture Come October

According to the calendar, the current tariff war between the U.S. and China began in early July. However, according to


Live from Trade Summit: No Reprieve for China’s Agchem Producers

Dr. Wayne Tan of CAC Group talks outlook for China's agchem companies amid the country's environmental crackdown.


Platform Confirms Arysta Sale to UPL, to Change Name

Platform has signed a definitive agreement to sell Arysta LifeScience Inc. to UPL Corporation Ltd. for $4.2 billion in cash, subject to customary closing adjustments Closing


Crop Protection Key to Doubling Indian Grower Income – Report

Despite all its achievements, Indian agriculture is still grappling with challenges like high monsoon dependency, unpredictable weather patterns, reduction in arable land, low per hectare yield, and lower farmer incomes.


Ning Replaces Ren as Syngenta Board Chair

Jianxin Ren, Chairman of the Board of Directors of Syngenta AG, has retired from the company's board.


Hemani Industries Launches Branded Formulation Division

Hemani Industries Limited, serving international agrichemical customers for more than three decades, has launched its branded formulation division to serve


From Plate to Plough: India Must Get its Agri-Markets Right

With the overarching concern for food security of 1.32 billion people, India’s policymakers have a challenging task, according to an


China Expects More Agricultural Imports from Europe

China is expanding trade ties with Europe by increasing imports of agriculture goods in a move that experts say won’t

Latest News


CropLife America Names Corteva’s Wasson as Chair

Wasson will hold the position for two years and use her diverse background to help guide the association, working with newly hired President and CEO Chris Novak.


Agricultural Robotics Take Center Stage at FIRA 2018

The future of agricultural innovation will continue to rely heavily on collaboration and exchange of ideas among all industry players.


What to Do If You Have Products Subject to New U.S. Tariffs

The new retaliation lists hit almost every product that the Chinese import from the U.S.

Industry News

China: We’ll Retaliate Against New U.S. Tariffs

China said on Tuesday that it had no choice but to retaliate against new U.S. trade tariffs, raising the risk

Plant Health

Soil Holds the Secret to Mitigating Climate Change

Food production doesn’t have to be a victim of climate change. New research from Michigan State University suggests that crop