Small Steps Are the Way for Sulphur Mills

Bimal Shah

While China’s industry deals with a difficult transformation, and India eyes the opportunity, the nuances of the situation can’t be overlooked. India is grappling with its own set of challenges, reminds Bimal Shah, Director of Mumbai-based Sulphur Mills Limited.

“India’s infrastructure is slower and movement takes time. Regulatory sometimes takes more time,” Shah says.

There is a concern that China could reverse course on its environmental crackdown, leaving India with overcapacity, and so India must be conservative. This cautious outlook is also rooted in a concern that overall use of synthetic chemistries will go down while biological-based products surge, he says.

While China could not go back to its former production ways overnight, “nor should India try something new overnight,” Shah said at the company’s meeting room at the AgriBusiness Global Trade Summit on Aug. 2. “India is not ready also – there is some dependence on backward integration, and a lot of intermediates still come out of China. It’s a good chance for India to buckle up and get the manufacturing and the backward integration into intermediates set-ups.”

“I see a good next five years, at least, to set the pace for the manufacturing in India. That is not for all raw materials from China, but 40% to 50% of raw materials I think is a fair number. Now, how fast it happens, how quick our infrastructure comes, and how fast the regulatory works – all of that is another thing.”

With this and other factors in mind, Sulphur Mills has chosen to take a more conservative approach to expansion than some of its competitors (the UPL-Arysta deal comes to mind).

“We were dependent on China for active ingredients, and one baby step we took was investing in our own facilities to add manufacturing of AIs and intermediates,” Shah says, “not only for ourselves but whatever we can part with also. But it’s more for internal consumption, and to be less dependent on other active and intermediate manufacturers and other companies in China,” he explains.

“Currently we have some basic older chemistries like chlorpyrifos, thiamethoxam, metrabuzin, and pendimethalin. We have additional land and are expanding the capacities of existing products or chain chemistries, which is something we feel that could be missing based on this whole environmental issue. We are looking at some new chemistries that are just coming off patent and deciding on new products and investments, which we should have more clear in the next two to three years.”

Sulphur Mills is also making more headway in formulation technology – it is India’s largest manufacturer of microencapsulations. The company has an R&D lab and develops and markets its own proprietary formulations, as well as for multinationals.

“We are looking for some forward integration for distribution, because more of our products require a lot of training — for the person who is trying to sell it, distribution who is going to use it, and the farmer who is going to apply it. We need to be able to show why the product is better than what is already being used,” he says, adding, “per kilo, it’s expensive, but per hectare it’s cheaper — if that isn’t explained right, then no matter if you have gold in your product.”

Shah on the uncertainty about the future:
“We see certain molecules disappearing too, such as some pyrethroids, because certain intermediates and chemicals that are available in China may not be available in other countries. We don’t know what is going to happen to those chemistries.

“India should not only be building in -1 but in -2, -3, -4 to be really backward integrated because otherwise there is still dependence. Lesser dependence is always good because there is so much uncertainty in China — the situation can change in five minutes. Forget a day.”

On Costs and Pricing:
“There is still a lot of dependency on China, but it needs to be more regulated. It can’t be just anybody making anything overnight without any policy or environmental conditions not looked at, so hence the cost is less. The Chinese government gives 11% to 13% as rebate on exports — that’s also a benefit for them. Of course, the cost is going to be less,” he continues.

“At the end of day, if you don’t have a cost of producing it the right way, you are cheaper. India has had a concern for the environment from the beginning, so the plants are expensive to run compared to China.

“Now China will go through the same things and have the same restrictions — the cost is going to increase. Because of the economy of scale and size of plants in China, there will be differences in pricing (with India) of course, but it won’t be drastic as earlier.”

On Investing in India:
“Even multinationals are having problems because they’ve set up a lot of their backward bases in China, and now they’re concerned. In fact, even Chinese companies are concerned that, ‘We don’t get to start here, so why don’t we invest in Indian companies and make something there?’ The laws are there, they are more stringent from the beginning and cost more, but you make the product, at least, rather than zero. In China, they are saying, ‘Go to Mongolia’ and do this and do that, and it’s not working well.

“That uncertainty in dealing with China — whether there is an environmental concern or something else — is always going to be there. That’s one thing with the Indian manufacturing base: the reliability of information and if something happens it is more long-term and stable. In this year or next year, too, if you’re buying something, you never know if your contract is going to be agreed, your timeline agreed, so there are a lot of issues. I think India has the benefit of reliability and sustainability. A lot of multinationals are now investing in India to manufacture their AIs or intermediates.”

Topics: , ,

Leave a Reply



Report: Farming in 20% of Indian Districts Threatened by Climate Change

Crops, plantations, even livestock in 151 districts, or slightly more than one-fifth of the total districts in India, are susceptible


Corteva to Launch New Fungicide, Starting in Asia Pacific

Corteva Agriscience announced Adavelt active as the new brand name for a novel fungicide that will offer farmers curative and


Marrone in Distribution Deal with Input Supplier in Turkey

Marrone Bio Innovations, Inc., a leading global provider of bio-based pest management and plant health products, announced that it has


Russia, Brazil Use Precision Ag Platform in Unexpected Ways

“For the first time ever, farmers are seeing that our imagery is as good as walking in the field. Farmers


ADAMA Hit by Drought in Europe, Higher Sourcing Costs

Shortage in certain raw materials and intermediates, mostly owing to increased environmental focus in China, led to higher procurement costs


U.S.-China Trade Forum Held Amid Trade Disputes

U.S.-China Agriculture Food Trade Forum was held Thursday in the western U.S. state of California, focusing on the promotion of


Opinion: Brazil’s Bolsonaro Can’t Afford to Upset Ties with China

Brazil’s far-right ex-army captain Jair Bolsonaro rode a wave of voter rage to the presidency on Sunday, writes CGTN’s Liu


Chilean Delegation Seeks Agricultural Collaboration with India

A high level agricultural Chilean delegation is arriving on Monday in India to talk about the new strategic guidelines of


Belchim Crop Protection: Reevaluating Sourcing

Belchim Crop Protection began hearing rumblings about China’s crackdown on manufacturers violating environmental regulations and potential supply disruptions in late


PMFAI Applauds Court Ruling Against Pesticide Imports without Technical Registration

The Pesticides Manufacturers & Formulators Association of India (PMFAI), a national association representing the Indian agrochemical industry, supports the Hon’ble


China Eases Pollution Campaign in Move to Offset U.S. Tariff Impact

China’s government announced it is scaling back its pollution control campaign this fall and winter, in an effort to offset


Fungicide Use on the Rise in Indonesia

The global crop protection market in 2017 increased at a rate of 1.9% in nominal terms over that of 2016.


BASF Launches Revysol Fungicide in South Korea

With the first global regulatory approval for the new compound received from South Korean authorities earlier this year, farmers in the country will be among the first in the world to benefit from the company’s latest offering.


Willowood USA to Hike Prices on Tariffs

Willowood the latest U.S. agrichemical company to announce price hikes.


Citing Tariff, Albaugh Raises Prices

"We are left with no alternative but to increase prices reflective of the higher tariffs."


India Could Fill Gap in Agricultural Imports Amid China-U.S. Trade War

The ongoing China-U.S. trade dispute will provide a chance for China and India to strengthen their agricultural trade, which will


What to Do If You Have Products Subject to New U.S. Tariffs

The new retaliation lists hit almost every product that the Chinese import from the U.S.


Trump Tariffs on Chinese Imports to Begin Sept. 24

Starting Jan. 1, 2019, the level of the additional tariffs will increase to 25 percent.

Pam Marrone

Marrone Enters Distribution Partnership in Vietnam, Cambodia

Key factors driving the rapid adoption of biologicals in Vietnam include pesticide residue problems in agro-products for local consumption, new requirements for Maximum Residue Levels on agro-products imported to the EU and U.S., and a growing number of banned pesticides.

Latest News


Terramera Gets EPA Approval for Biocontrol Product

Terramera announced the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency approved registration of its novel, broad-spectrum agricultural insect, fungal disease, and mite control

Industry News

Cibus Files Registration Statement for Proposed Initial Public Offering

Cibus Ltd., a leader in advanced plant-breeding technologies, has publicly filed a registration statement on Form S-1 with the U.S.


What to Expect for U.S. Dicamba Use in 2019

Long-awaited news from U.S. Environmental Protection Agency on its decision to extend the registration for the new dicamba technologies arrived Halloween


Report: Farming in 20% of Indian Districts Threatened by Climate Change

Crops, plantations, even livestock in 151 districts, or slightly more than one-fifth of the total districts in India, are susceptible


Bayer: Study Shows its Soybeans Reduce Environmental Impact

Results from a five-year peer-reviewed study on Intacta RR2 PRO™ soybeans planted in South America were recently published, indicating that