Opinion: Trump’s Trans-Pacific Partnership Decision a Head Scratcher

Editor’s Note: Matthew J. Grassi is Field Editor with CropLife® magazine a sister publication to AgriBusiness Global. Matthew can be reached at [email protected]

U.S. President Donald Trump has just dealt domestic agriculture interests a tremendous blow, in this author’s opinion, by withdrawing American participation in the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP).

A little background: for the past two years I’ve listened to former Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack, a man I’ve come to greatly respect for his thoughtful temperament and moderate legislative style, practically beg for Congressional urgency in getting TPP approved at his annual appearance at the Commodity Classic show, and it seemed like we were getting close. All politics aside, I feel TPP was, and still is, a good deal for U.S. soybean producers and grain marketers.

I understand this is part of The Donald’s repertoire and mass appeal to his blue-collar base: screw the rest of the world, let’s look out for our interests first and foremost (this in itself is a bit scary, considering how global an industry agriculture truly is, but CropLife is not the forum for that debate). #MAGA

But I’d argue, if you’ll allow me, that if President Trump were truly beholden to the interests of the rural, often employed-in-agriculture Americans that propelled him into office in November (at least here in Ohio, the major urban areas all went Hillary; rural Ohio — where soybeans are big business — overwhelmingly went to Trump), he’d recognize that with this decision he is just making it more difficult for an already over-supplied U.S. grain exporting industry to make the American producer whole again. And with no end in sight to brutal commodity prices that are making it harder and harder for farmers to turn a profit on the acre, that, for lack of a better word, sucks.

It also should be noted that President Trump made this decision without input from a sitting Secretary of Agriculture. Why not just wait for Sonny Perdue to be confirmed by Congress, before making a potentially irreversible decision on TPP? Why the rush, mere days after taking office? Are we legislating by the seat of our pants here, Mr. President? Trying to win the press conference, albeit at the expense of the American soybean farmer?

So. Many. Questions.

Since I’m having trouble expressing myself eloquently here, I’ll let Ron Moore, himself an American farmer and president of the American Soybean Association, say it for me.

“Trade is something soybean farmers take very seriously. We export more than half the soy we grow here in the United States, and still more in the form of meat and other products that are produced with our meal and oil,” said Moore, who farms in Roseville, Ill, in recent comments distributed by the group. “The TPP held great promise for us, and has been a key priority for several years now. We’re very disappointed to see the withdrawal today.”

There are numbers that bare out Moore’s disappointment; I’m not sure anyone from the current administration has given us definitive data (alternative facts, anyone?) that shows just why President Trump opposed entry into the TPP, but I’d welcome such a discussion.

Here’s some data that ASA provided to backup its position on TPP:

According to the ASA release, soybeans are the nation’s largest agricultural export, and markets in Southeast Asia and Latin America continue to grow in their potential as buyers of U.S. soy, as those populations gradually move to a more protein-based diet. TPP countries currently represent about 40% of the world’s gross domestic product (GDP), and according to the Peterson Institute, American participation would have increased overall U.S. exports by $357 billion by 2030. Specifically for U.S. farmers, TPP would have increased annual net farm income by $4.4 billion, according to the American Farm Bureau Federation.

Anecdotally, many have argued that U.S. withdrawal from TPP will give Chinese agricultural interests a leg-up in the TPP markets, allowing China to negotiate trade agreements that could block future U.S. grain marketing opportunities in the region.

Now, for their part Trump supporters will counter that he intends to negotiate individual trade agreements with each of the key players in TPP, chiefly Japan, but it remains to be seen if he can get it done in a timely fashion. I will admit the man, for all his faults, does seem to have a knack for negotiation. However, as Republican Senator Chuck Grassley recently stated, “it’s just not an easy thing to do.”

Hopefully President Trump can deliver on those trade agreements for U.S. farmers, the same folks that so enthusiastically embraced and supported his campaign in the first place. Right now he seems more interested in initiatives around heavy manufacturing (where he has many business “friends” that stand to benefit) and keeping factories in the country…and tweeting (couldn’t help myself).

I just hope he doesn’t forget about all of the food manufacturing that helps support our way of life here in flyover country. After they turned out in such large numbers in 2016 to support him, he certainly owes Rural Americans more than that.

Topics: ,



Syngenta Reports 2017 Half-Year Results

Innovation and productivity savings have partially offset weak market conditions for Syngenta in the first half of 2017. The company


Bayer-Monsanto Merger Will Grow, Not Stifle, Innovation in Agriculture

Bayer’s acquisition of Monsanto has some critics concerned that the merger would deter innovation in the agricultural sector and impact


DuPont Gets Boost From Farmers With Dow Merger Set to Close

DuPont Co. got a boost from U.S. farmers as it closes in on the historic $75 billion merger with Dow


Dow Executive Named New CEO at Lindsay Corp.

Lindsay Corp. has  announced the appointment of Timothy Hassinger as president and CEO and a member of its board of


Complexity in Agriculture: The Rise (and Fall?) of Monsanto

Sometimes it seems as if the ag world is changing so fast that we can barely keep up with it


ChemChina Participation in Syngenta Exceeds 98% Threshold

Following the purchase of additional Syngenta shares, ChemChina’s participation in Syngenta has exceeded 98% of Syngenta’s share capital. As a


As Drift Complaints Snowball, Tennessee Sets New Dicamba Rules

While stopping short of a ban, Tennessee sets stricter application parameters for the herbicide.


BASF Responds to Dicamba Restrictions in Arkansas, Missouri

"Recent actions taken in Arkansas and Missouri to ban or restrict the use of dicamba herbicides, including BASF’s Engenia, deprive farmers of the one option that has proven effective in controlling this worrisome, yield-robbing issue."


China Launches Anti-Dumping Probe on India Imports

China's Weifang Runnong Chemical claims that India exported MPB at a lower price than the normal value, which has led to continuous price decreases in China’s domestic market.


Dow to Sell Part of Corn Seed Business to CITIC Agri Fund

Transaction marks continued progress in proposed Dow and DuPont transaction.


Bayer, Netafirm Develop New Smart Irrigation Approach

Market launch is planned in Mexico by the end of 2017.

Africa/Middle East

South Africa Conditionally Approves Dow, DuPont Merger

The decision follows recent conditional approvals from global antitrust authorities in Canada and Mexico and from the U.S. Department of Justice on June 15.


Insecticide Seed Treatment Market to Grow to $5.04 Billion by 2022

Neonicotinoids are projected to be the fastest-growing chemical sub-type between 2017 and 2022.


CropLife America: States’ Decisions on Dicamba Premature

CropLife America issued the following statement on July 10: Over the last couple weeks, both Missouri and Arkansas state governments


China’s Exports Drop in 2016

The U.S. and Brazil remain major markets for China’s crop protection exports.


Monsanto Responds to Arkansas, Missouri Dicamba Bans

"We sympathize with any farmers experiencing crop injury, but the decision to ban dicamba in Arkansas was premature since the causes of any crop injury have not been fully investigated."


Missouri Becomes Second U.S. State to Ban Dicamba

Missouri, Arkansas take action to stop sale and use of dicamba following hundreds of drift complaints.


Heads of R&D, Global Operations to Leave Syngenta

Trish Malarkey, Head of R&D and Mark Peacock, Head of Global Operations will leave Syngenta at the end of September 2017.


Arkansas Governor Moves to Ban Dicamba

Arkansas Governor Asa Hutchinson on Friday said he has decided to back the Arkansas State Plant Board’s proposal to ban dicamba in the state, as the “volume of complaints justify emergency action.”

Latest News


India’s ‘Protectionist Bent’ for Agricultural Products Delaying FTA with Australia

Australian trade minister Steve Ciobo has said India has adopted a “reasonably protectionist bent” for its agricultural products, delaying any


How The Internet Of Things Is Digitizing Agriculture, Speeding Up Rural Development in India

The Internet of Things (IoT) revolution in India is catching on with increasing government and venture capital investments pouring into


DuPont Pioneer, Evogene Form Research Collaboration for Development of Corn Biostimulant Products

DuPont Pioneer and Evogene Ltd., a leading company for the improvement of crop productivity and economics for the food, feed


Gowan Crop Protection Completes Acquisition of Agrotechnology in Chile

Gowan Crop Protection Ltd., an affiliate of Gowan Co., L.L.C., has announced the completion of its acquisition of Agrotechnology S.A.


Syngenta Reports 2017 Half-Year Results

Innovation and productivity savings have partially offset weak market conditions for Syngenta in the first half of 2017. The company